Dear Susan Sarandon,
Let me start this by saying that I admire some of your work as an actress, yes I have seeing some of your movies, who hasn't! Also I had followed your activism against war, violence, racism, children abuse, and homophobia, and especially in defense of human rights in the world. Thanks Susan, you rock.
That is why I was really disappointed when I saw the images that went around the world, showing you standing in front of Machu Picchu, surrounded by Indigenous children of Peru. The news said that you went to Cusco for the reopening of Machu Picchu, which was closed to the public for two months after heavy rains destroyed the access from Cusco.
Machu Picchu is a citadel built by the Quechua Indigenous peoples under the rule of Inka Pachacuti in the 15th century. It was created for educational, recreational and mostly religious purposes –not a fortress as some European news agencies are saying.
Firstly, and please Susan don’t take this in the wrong way but to me, it really looked racist to have a European-descendant woman reopening an Indigenous sacred place as Machu Picchu. This is a historical site that was left almost intact because the invader Hispanics never found it.
You see, Peru is a post colonial country created by a European invasion on Native people's land. The process of colonization is still happening today, especially in the lands of Indigenous peoples which are rich in natural resources. I say this not to attack you or any other European descendant person, but to ask you to think carefully about your trip to Peru.
Ask yourself if you did the right thing.
It turns out that you were invited to Machu Picchu by the Peruvian government, through PromPeru its agency for tourism promotion, and of course all expenses were paid, including your stay in luxurious hotels in Lima and Cusco, in rooms that went from $350 to $700 dollars per night, in a country where the minimum wage is about $205 dollars monthly.
This I just confirmed this with PromPeru over the phone.I was told by PromPeru that you also spent money of your own with your family. Seems like you had a good time!
But since you care about equality and human rights, I have no doubt that during your trip to Peru you noticed the offensive and unjustified gap between the rich and the poor, among Peruvians. I’m sure you saw Indigenous and Afro descendant children begging for money in the streets of Lima, Cusco and Puno. Perhaps while being there and I deeply hope so, you noticed how racist Peruvian society is.
In case you didn’t see any of that, let me remind you that last year, Peru’s president Alan Garcia said that Indigenous peoples aren’t first class citizens; he said this while justifying the massacre of hundreds of Amazonian natives in the Bagua region.
Susan Sarandon, please send a check to the government of Peru returning the money spent in your trip, and ask them to use the funds to help the victims of the floods in Cusco, Apurimac, Ayacucho, and Puno; or to build hospitals for the children of the Andes.
So let me ask you some more questions, dear Susan.
How did you feel when you were in Peru with your best friend and family, seeing the extreme level of poverty, the lack of decent housing, roads, schools, and hospitals among the Native communities? Did you see the horrendous inequality in living conditions between the tourist-only areas and the rest of the cities that you visited? Did you look at the immense shanty towns around the cosmopolitan city of Lima, while the plane landed?
Did you know that two days after you officially "reopened" Machu Picchu, the government you represented killed 5 miners and 1 civilian during protests in Chala, in southern Peru?
How would you feel if at the reopening of Ground Zero in your beloved NYC, a foreign artist would be invited to lead the ceremony? Not to promote hatred here but we know that everything has its place and time.
These questions are intended only to remind you Susan Sarandon, of your commitment for social justice. You can’t look the other way and pretend everything is alright in Peru. You cannot deny that such a disparity in opportunities seeing in Peru is only the result of an unfair, racist and discriminatory model of development, economy, and government.
Perhaps you weren’t aware dear Susan of this. Every year hundreds of Indigenous peoples in Peru including children die of cold weather related diseases in the Andean region. These casualties are perfectly preventable. The children you hugged for the pictures, their parents are not allowed in the same train with foreign tourists, because according to British-owned Peru Rail, that way they keep people safer.
Since January this year, thousands of people have lost their homes in Cusco and many towns in southern Peru, due to heavy rain that caused huge floods and mudslides. Most of them are still in need of help.
The same government that invited you to reopen Machu Picchu has done little or nothing to help the victims of these natural disasters in Peru. Same is the scenario for thousands of Peruvians who lost their homes in Chincha Alta and Pisco, after the 2007 earthquake. They are still live in shacks and cabins made of plastic, board and garbage.
The government of Peru and its agency PromPeru say that they invited you –and plan to invite other celebrities- to attract visitors to Cusco. Don’t take offense Susan, but Machu Picchu doesn’t need you to get the international attention and to attract tourists.
Think about Cusco and its people for a moment. Most of the historical sites of that region were mostly by our Indigenous civilizations before the European contact, and they are the biggest attraction for almost 2 million tourists that come to Peru annually.
Guess what, most of those places and all tourism industry around them, are managed or owned by corporations from Lima and foreign countries, especially the U.S. and Europe. Cusco people get the leftovers.
So, in behalf of the people of Cusco and of the children you took pictures with for the international press and in the name of Machu Picchu, Susan Sarandon I’m asking you to consider helping the people of Peru by taking simple, decent and necessary steps:
Please send a check to the government of Peru returning the money spent in your trip, and ask them to use the funds to help the victims of the floods in Cusco, Apurimac, Ayacucho, and Puno; or to build hospitals for the children of the Andes.
Then you can demand the Garcia administration to stop signing special decrees that are opening 73% of the Amazon forest and the Andean mountains to destructive corporations, for extractive industries like mining, oil and natural gas.
You can also demand them to stop racist policies that allow the genocide of poorest Peruvians: Blacks and Natives, while promoting a White supremacist government. It’s not your fault that you were used by the Peruvian government.
Susan Sarandon, I trust your sense of humanity and solidarity. Peruvians who are oppressed and left behind will thank you, you will be really doing some good activism this way.
Oh, in case my letter is not convincing enough, please Susan read what your countryman has to say in a more direct way.
Sincerely, Peruanista.
Susan Sarandon with Peru's Tourism Minister Martin Perez (L) and Machu Picchu Mayor Edgar Miranda (R) arrive in Machu Picchu town, April 1, 2010. Photo ReutersPhoto by Juan Franco


Wow! Carlos, this is deep. Thanks for the news. I hope she will in fact see her mistake.
ReplyDeleteHay peruanista, y luego dices que no eres racista. Solo una persona 100% indigena puede reabrir Machu Picchu? Podria hacerlo yo? Yo tengo sangre indigena e italiana. Soy rubio y en Peru me dicen gringo. Soy lo suficientemente peruano para reabrir Machu Picchu? Con que "raza" me tendria que sentir identificado? Y sobre los trenes... al menos cuando yo visite Cuzco en 2006, los peruanos podiamos viajar en cualquiera de los trenes a Machu Picchu. Eran los extranjeros los que no podian viajar en el tren mas economico (el de 10 soles si mal no recuerdo). Claro que el mas barato para turistas (el Backpacker) costaba alrededor de 50$; Lo que hacia que la mayoria de peruanos optaran por el mas tren mas barato.
ReplyDeleteSaludos
jaja, me has hecho reir con esta carta, como si la actriz esa fuera a leerla, como si ella leera tu blog. Jajaj Ubicate Peruanista....pero bueno , esta bueno el chiste.....jajaja. Te falta calle o esquina como dicen en Lima. Pero claro, tu trabajas en McDonald's friendo hamburguesas para los yanquis..que vas a saber...
ReplyDeleteJefferson Chefloque
Respectfully, I disagree strongly with this article.
ReplyDelete1. I disagree with the idea that a blogger who remains behind a pseudonym can start every paragraph with the name of an individual. It's bullying. Cyber bullying. I guess you think she has enough money to make it okay, though.
2. How is limiting tourism in Cusco going to help native peoples there? Most rich foreigners think the place is dangerous, right now, are still remembering the airlifting from the landslides story, and going to spend their tourist dollar at the Valley of the Kings in Egypt instead. Publicising that Machu Picchu is open again is going to provide an income to a lot of people, many of them quechua.
3. Yes, as a "wonder of the world", Machu Picchu will always have tourists. But it won't have the tourists who pay a fair living wage to the people who work in the industry. You must know the difference between what a mochilera will pay for a room and what a retired wealthy couple will pay.
4. The colonization of the indígenas of Perú was a horrific thing. But the Incas [*] And yet you reserve the right to call people racist. Reverse racism is also racism, mate. I usually enjoy your campaigns on racial awareness in Perú, but I don't think this one helps much.
5. Speaking of that, the whole "gringa! help them!" thing that Oxfam does is itself inherently raicst. Build structures that allow a society to stand on its own feet, don't worsen the situation by demanding handouts.
6. Were Ms Sarandon to return the cost of her marketing trip (marketing for Aguas Calientes, remember, and only peripherally for Susan Sarandon Inc), would it go to the indigenous peoples of the Urubamba region? Would it? I think not. I think García or the next incumbent or whoever would pocket it to pay for his own purposes.
In principal, I agree, it could have been done better. But there's something I find distasteful about the tone of this post. Sorry to be a naysayer, I think you normally consider things more deeply than this. Feel free to disagree.
(*) Note from Peruanista: I have edited this comment and deleted offensive lies about the Indigenous history. This blog is not promoting hatred against any racial or cultural group.
Note to the readers:
ReplyDeleteThis blog is against all types of racism. I will continue writing against the horrendous inequality that exists in Peru.
The tourism industry in Cusco is discriminatory, corrupt, racist and benefits little to the people of Cusco where 75% of the population lives in extreme poverty.
A person who works for Susan Sarandon has received this letter and has promised to forward this to the actress and activist.
Thank you for reading Peruanista.
Firstly? Peruanista maybe you should reconsider taking some grammar courses.
ReplyDeleteLearn English before writing a letter, I can't even get past your first sentence: "I have seeing some of your movies..." do you mean "I have seen"?
ReplyDeletei could have not said this better myself. i hope Susan Sarandon listens. way to go
ReplyDeleteLastimosamente cuando alguien no encuentra argumentos para responder alturadamente lo primero que buscan es el error gramatical... algunas personas realmente dan mucha mas pena no por los errores gramaticales sino porque no tienen la capacidad de entender lo que estan leyendo.
ReplyDeleteCarlos en esta ocasion te doy la razon. Se pasaron de huachafos invitando a Susan.
Saludos,